Page 1 of 1

frothy water

Posted: Fri Aug 16, 2019 8:11 pm
by hazzard
Has anyone experienced frothy water in their major's radiator water? My 1960 Power has new radiator, it froths up after a bit of light work and spits water out of the overflow. If I take the radiator cap off the water is very frothy. Any clues please?

Re: frothy water

Posted: Fri Aug 16, 2019 8:45 pm
by shepp
Sounds very much like a blown cylinder head gasket or loose cylinder head bolts which are allowing combustion gases from one or more cylinders into the cooling system and pressurising the coolant - the froth is the escaped gas. You could try checking the cylinder head bolts for tightness, to do this you will need a torque wrench and a sequence chart found in the workshop manual and tighten down the head bolts in the order shown to a torque setting of 85 to 90 lb.ft
This might work, if not you will have to remove the cylinder head and replace the head gasket.

Re: frothy water

Posted: Sun Aug 18, 2019 5:48 pm
by hazzard
shepp wrote:Sounds very much like a blown cylinder head gasket or loose cylinder head bolts which are allowing combustion gases from one or more cylinders into the cooling system and pressurising the coolant - the froth is the escaped gas. You could try checking the cylinder head bolts for tightness, to do this you will need a torque wrench and a sequence chart found in the workshop manual and tighten down the head bolts in the order shown to a torque setting of 85 to 90 lb.ft
This might work, if not you will have to remove the cylinder head and replace the head gasket.
Yes I thought it might be something to do with the head...I shall tighten the head down and see if that fixes it. Thanks.

Re: frothy water

Posted: Sun Aug 18, 2019 9:51 pm
by mathias1
hazzard wrote:
shepp wrote:Sounds very much like a blown cylinder head gasket or loose cylinder head bolts which are allowing combustion gases from one or more cylinders into the cooling system and pressurising the coolant - the froth is the escaped gas. You could try checking the cylinder head bolts for tightness, to do this you will need a torque wrench and a sequence chart found in the workshop manual and tighten down the head bolts in the order shown to a torque setting of 85 to 90 lb.ft
This might work, if not you will have to remove the cylinder head and replace the head gasket.
Yes I thought it might be something to do with the head...I shall tighten the head down and see if that fixes it. Thanks.
start in the middle and work your way around to both ends

Re: frothy water

Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2019 8:54 pm
by hazzard
Thanks. :D

Re: frothy water

Posted: Wed Aug 21, 2019 6:46 am
by Pavel
" Yes I thought it might be something to do with the head...I shall tighten the head down and see if that fixes it. Thanks."[/quote]

But don't forget, Hazzard, to 'crack' [loosen] each fastener a half turn first. And don't loosen the whole lot before re-torque -- do them one at a time.
If you are, hopefully, successful you then have the job of getting rid of the gunk clogging the radiator tubes.
Good luck!
Pavel

Re: frothy water

Posted: Wed Aug 21, 2019 9:55 am
by oehrick
Would you do this with the engine hot, warm or cold Pavel ? I tend to do a new gasket warm but that would be with all threads cleaned, I'd probably go for hot with an old gasket and unknown thread condition.
I've often wondered what the difference in actual clamping pressure there might be as the bolt torque is the resistance tor turning, depends on pressure being applied but frictional resistance to turning must vary appreciably between dry and rusted and squeeky clean and lubricated - anyone on the forum know the answer ??

Hope retorquing solves your problem hazzard

Re: frothy water

Posted: Wed Aug 21, 2019 11:40 am
by SvendH
Owners manuel says re torque with warm engine .

Re: frothy water

Posted: Thu Aug 22, 2019 10:44 am
by Pavel
In the old days, Rick,the general practice was to re-torque engines after they were warmed up -- and as SvendH has stated, our good book recommends this.
As far as I recall the reason was that head bolts/studs expanded slightly with heat and therefor fractionally loosen.
But by far the worst problem with bolt fasteners was/is gunge, and/or oil, still retained in the threaded bolt sockets which, therefor, allow false readings. Studs don't have this problem.
Reading a fastener manufacturers 'bible' states that the thread of bolts and studs should be clean and lightly oiled prior to tightening.

Rick; reference your, and others, post some days ago.
As a fifteen year old in the early '50s I remember being taught, and allowed to operate, a petrol Fergie. This, and a couple of others on the farm near Salisbury, had a stater motor operated by the gear lever -- sort of a fifth gear position. Obviously this was a good fail safe against starting whilst in gear.
Pavel

Re: frothy water

Posted: Thu Aug 22, 2019 12:53 pm
by oehrick
Yes that is my understanding too Pavel, but how much difference dirty / seized bolts make compared too cleaned and oiled threads I have no idea, 10%, 50%, 100% ??.

In my view the problem is entirely different to torqueing down a newly fitted head since this particular problem involves torquing down what may be last tightened in the 1950's bolts on a possibly fully torqued gasket joint, we know that undoing these bolts presents a reasonable chance of breakage due to seizure so just further tightening gives even more risk of breakage. I think we should be considering taking the bolts out one at a time, following the usual sequence, cleaning and lubing the thread, pulling back down to say 75-80% of full torque then moving to the next one (a long tap to clean the thread in the block would be a handy thing) once all are back in place then follow the sequence to get back to full torque, I would be doing this with the engine hot rather than warm.

Do you think this is overkill ? at a bare minimum the bolts need to be released a couple of turns before retightening !

As for the LGM and it's gearbox safety position for starting, I've often wondered why this was not more widely used, perhaps tractor drivers were more intelligent or the makers considered them disposable! either way the odd reminder that as we get older we tend to get wiser to the risks and more likely to take a chance is useful, like not standing under a raised trailer body or front loader !

Hope your winter is not being too hot or wet :)

Re: frothy water

Posted: Wed Sep 25, 2019 6:00 pm
by scarecrow
hello there
Frothy water sounds pretty much like fenland beer, but have you had the thermostat out and tried working
it without for a couple of days, it could be the problem, its worked for me before now, you can always boil it
in a pan of water to see if it opens up ( but best wait while the missis goes shopping)

Re: frothy water

Posted: Thu Sep 26, 2019 12:30 pm
by fenhayman
Frothy water sounds pretty much like fenland beer
Scarecrow ought to try a few pints of Elgoods of Wisbech Ales. OK you might just taste the Nene river water but frothy water they are not.
We prefer full glasses of beer in the fens, not those topped with two inches of froth!